Composting VS Incinerating Toilet for Tiny House: Which are The Best

When it comes to tiny house toilets there are plenty of options on the market. Composting toilets are one of the most popular options for tiny house toilets. This toilet will naturally break down your solid waste into compost through decomposition. You can use compost as a fertilizer to hit two birds with one stone.

Composting toilets have obtained popularity in poo disposal of the tiny house for several reasons. They are environmentally friendly, need no water, electricity or gas, and will be built small to suit in any size tiny house. They are simple because they use traditional waste management technology.

Cost is another important factor for a tiny house. Among all of these advantages, a composting toilet is affordable too. They also don’t require any water or sewer systems. They can break-down waste without the necessity of water or stinky chemicals. Also, they are pretty simple and easy to maintain. 

When you think about your tiny house toilet, a composting toilet possibly is the first option in your mind. It’s gained great popularity for numerous reasons. 

Composting VS Incinerating Toilet for Tiny House: Which are The Best

Advantages of Composting Toilet:

Composting toilets have many more advantages. They are-

• Budget-friendly and Economical.
• Faster installation and minimum maintenance.
• No water, electricity or gas required.
• Environmental friendly.
• Produces nutrient-rich fertilizer.

Disadvantages of Composting Toilet:

Composting toilets have some disadvantages too, such as-

• Requirement to work on waste material directly.
• Sometimes it produces some smell.

Frequently Asked Questions of Composting Toilet:

• How do composting toilets work?

Answer: Composting toilets naturally break down your solid waste into nutrient compost by decomposition. You can use the compost as a fertilizer to hit two birds with one stone. No water, electricity or gas is required to get the nutrient-rich fertilizer.

• How often do you have to empty a composting toilet?

Answer: Usually, a composting toilet is designed for full-time of one to four people full-time. Full-time usage of two people normally need emptying nearly every 3 weeks. The time to empty will shorten in case of additional people. Nature’s Head suggests dumping after every 60-80 time of usage. It’s also depending on how much toilet paper you can use.

• How do composting toilets work in tiny houses?

Answer: Nature’s Head like urine-diverting composting toilet works by separating the liquid and solid waste in two different compartments. In truth, a composting toilet works better in a tiny house than a traditional flush toilet. You can minimise the smell of waste by separating them into two separate compartments.

Tiny House Toilet Options: Incinerating Toilet:

Incinerating toilets is another popular off-grid toilet option for tiny houses. Incinerating toilets burns your waste into a tablespoon of sterile ash residue with electric or gas energy. It’s simply an evaporation process because most of the waste is mostly moisture. 

This means these are mostly eco-friendly, apart from the small amount of fuel to burn the waste. They also don’t need water, sewer or septic systems. This may be the best option for tiny house types in a small space.

However, the main drawback is they’re more costly than the composting toilets. New model might cost you more than a thousand dollars. There is also the complexity involved in using it. Although most of the smell is vented to the outdoors, they’re still smelly. Burning poop isn’t the best odour even though it’s not as smells indoors. 

Overall, incinerating toilets is an off-grid solution especially suitable for a tiny house. They are environmentally friendly but complicated and costly. You can consider an incinerating toilet when you have enough budget for a tiny house toilet. 

TinyJohn Incinerating Toilet by Eco John is one of the best high-quality incinerating toilets, but it will cost you a lot. As a substitute, you can consider Villa 9215 AC/DC  when you want a cheaper alternative.

Advantages of Incinerating Toilet:

Incinerating toilets have many advantages. They are-

• Environmental friendly.
• No water, septic or sewer require.
• No composting needed.
• Produces teaspoon of sterile ashes.

Disadvantages of Incinerating Toilet:

Incinerating toilets have some disadvantages too, such as-

• More costly than composting toilets.
• Require energy to burn waste.

Frequently Asked Questions of Incinerating Toilet 

• How does an incinerating toilet work?

Answer: Incinerating toilets burn your waste into a tablespoon of sterile free ash with the use of gas or electric heat. The inside of the toilet is made of metal so that it doesn’t melt during the incineration process. Incineration chamber instantly burned the waste and turned into Living in a tiny house doesn’t mean that you have to use an outhouse. Tiny house toilet is one of the most essential tiny house decisions you’ll make. Because, when you stay in a small house, your toilet becomes a big deal. The type of toilet you decide for your tiny house you use for years, so this decision you should not make lightly. 

There are lots of toilet options for tiny houses, the question is which toilet is best for your tiny house? Commonly, composting toilets and incinerating toilets are popular for many tiny house homeowners. So what’s the difference between these two toilets and which ones are the best for a tiny house?

Composting toilets naturally break down your solid waste into nutrient compost by decomposition. Incinerating toilets burn your waste into a tablespoon of sterile free ash with the use of electric or gas heat.

While a composting toilet is energy efficient and less expensive than the incinerating toilet, it also needs more work, sometimes produces smell. It’s important to know how these two toilets work and the major differences between them to pick the best toilet for your tiny house. In this article, we’ll discuss all about the composting vs incinerating toilet and which is better for your tiny house. 

Tiny House Toilet Options:Composting Toilet:

sterile free ash

• Are incinerating toilets eco-friendly?

Answer: Every incineration lasts 10-20 minutes, and one tablespoon of sterile ash residue remains with every defecation. This is because about 98% of waste is moisture, so the incineration is simply an evaporation process. It’s indicated incinerating toilets are usually eco-friendly, apart from the small amount of fuel needed to burn the waste.

• Does an incinerating toilet smell?

Answer: Incinerating toilets usually use electric or gas heat to burn waste into a tablespoon amount of sterile ash. Although, the system is nearly odour-free but burning isn’t an odourless process. Burning your waste isn’t odourless, but the smell is lesser than the composting toilet.

Composting VS Incinerating Toilet:

Function:

Composting toilets naturally break down your solid waste into nutrient compost. Incinerating toilets burn your waste into a tablespoon of sterile free ash with the electric or gas heat. These both practically operate with no water, making them suitable for small places such as tiny houses.

Cost:

Cost is always a considerable factor for any budget-conscious cabin owner. Composting toilets is less costly ($800 -$3000) than incinerating toilets ($1,200–$4,000). Composting toilets are an attractive option for tiny house owners with a limited budget.

Comfort:

Composting toilets don’t give you much comfort when compared with an incinerating toilet. Many users are uncomfortable with regularly dumping waste into a compost pile. Incinerating toilet is comfortable especially when you don’t like extra work. Simply press the button and then your waste turns into sterile ash, no extra work needed.

Disposal:

Composting toilets is an excellent option when you have a green garden. You can use compost as a fertilizer to hit two birds with one stone. On the other hand, ash from incinerating toilets aren’t reusable like the compost.

Smell:

Composting toilets can produce some smell in your tiny house. But you can minimize the smell with proper seal and wrap. Still, you have to deal with the smell during the time of clean. Oppositely, burning your waste isn’t totally odourless, but the smell is smaller than a composting toilet.

Environmental Friendly:

They both are environmentally friendly as they save water. But, composting is more environmental when it comes to composting vs incinerating toilets. Incinerating toilets require energy and don’t save natural waste like composting toilets.

When you think about tiny house toilets, a composting toilet is possibly the first option in your mind. That’s why we’ll review a composting toilet with all of the advantages. This discussion will help you to make your buying decision for your tiny house.

Best Composting Toilet In 2021: Nature’s Head Self Contained Composting Toilet

Although there are a lot of options to choose a composting toilet, Nature’s Head would be the most similar to an actual toilet. You will find this brand as the best when you have done your research. This is an eco-friendly, self-contained waterless operation system. It’s compact, and lightweight making it one of the best options for tiny house applications.

Most important, this toilet doesn’t have the disgusting odour related with all other systems. The air circulation fan recycles the air in the bathroom to make the environment smell better.

Moreover, it was initially designed for marine use. As a result, its robust design and materials prove to be durable in case of any environment. It has durable construction design to defeat the harshest of conditions.

Nature’s Head is one of the best seller composting toilets in 2021. It’s a reliable option with the latest design for a tiny house.

 

Which Is The Best Toilet for Tiny House?

The best toilet for your tiny house completely depends on what you’re searching for. Many tiny house owners satisfied with composting toilets and many are comfortable with incinerating toilets. So, which is the best toilet option for a tiny house? 

There’s no exact answer, as all two types have their benefits and flaws. Composting toilets are the most common solution for relative low cost. That doesn’t mean you only consider composting toilets as a solution for your special needs. Consider these two types, and then correlate your options on function, price, and where you’ll live. 

If cost isn’t a big issue, you can consider incinerating toilets for tiny house toilet solutions. You have to think less about your waste, but you’ll pay more initial purchase, fuel and installation. On the other hand, the composting toilet should be superb for your tiny house with economic costs. Always select the toilet that suits best for your small house lifestyle.  

Conclusion:

There are many options on the market when it comes to tiny house toilets. Composting and incinerating toilets is the most common for many tiny house homeowners. So, which one is the best toilet for your tiny house? 

Although composting vs incinerating toilets depends on your purpose. Many tiny house owners are satisfied with composting toilets. Knowing your need, expectation, and budget will help you select a toilet that suits your tiny house lifestyle.